Hey! I just joined here after trying to join Reddit. They banned me without explanation. Twice. Very glad I discovered Lemmy. Seems even better! Thanks to all the Lemmards! Hehhee
Hey! I just joined here after trying to join Reddit. They banned me without explanation. Twice. Very glad I discovered Lemmy. Seems even better! Thanks to all the Lemmards! Hehhee
You’re going find that most of the instances on lemmy will likewise ban you for the same thing; but not all of them (especially not the one I’m commenting on) and it’s easy to regain access even if you are banned.
Check to see which instances the mods of a community come from to determine if pointing out a psyop will get you banned before posting/commenting
Mate… You’re on .ml. Go post something that’s anti-Russia, China or DPRK and see how long it takes you to get banned.
The ban would be on that instance or the whole lemmy?
Usually a temp ban for a day or two (up to a month or so depending on how bad), and usually only on one community on one instance. You can’t be banned from all of Lemmy unless your own instance admin bans you.
Kobold broke the rules down the comment thread, and was banned for 2 weeks from this community alone, as an example.
Ok. Thanks for the clarification!
What rules did he break?
Yep, as @Edie@lemmy.ml said!
You can see the modlog for a user (assuming you are using the Lemmy through the web, I’m not sure about apps) by clicking the three dots with an downarss pointing arrow and then clicking on “[username] Moderation History”
You can critique socialist states as long as they are critiqued from a grounded position not colored by imperialist consent manufacturing, and you can definitely critique the Russian Federation as it hasn’t been socialist since the early 90s.
Posting anti Russian/China/DPRK is how I learned that I’ve been unwittingly propagating propaganda as an American.
It’s those people to double down on their brain washing despite being presented w proof that they’re wrong are the ones who get banned.
Wow boys this escalated quickly.
Here’s what I think. Fuck USSR. Maybe my take is a little biased because my parents and grandparents grew up under its oppression and I know hundreds of people whose families were killed or sent to the deep end of Russia and left there to die. Many of them died. Many walked for years back home because of the Love of their country.
You can’t imagine the relief everyone felt when it finally collapsed. That we preserved our language and culture despite of all the efforts to erase us.
Only people who glorify that trash are alcoholic diaspora who were left behind by their great regime and dumbasses who have no idea what they are talking about.
The USSR had steady and consistent economic growth, and provided free, high quality education and healthcare, full employment, cheap or free housing, and fantastic infrastructure and city planning. This rapid development resulted in dramatic democratization of society, reduced disparity, doubling of life expectancy, tripling of functional literacy rates to 99.9%, and much more. Living in the 1930s famine would not have been good, but it was the last major famine outside of wartime because the soviets ended famine in their countries.
Literacy rates, societal guarantees in the 1936 constitution, reports on the healthcare system over time, and more are good sources for these claims.
The USSR brought dramatic democratization to society. First-hand accounts from Statesian journalist Anna Louise Strong in her book This Soviet World describe soviet elections and factory councils in action. Statesian Pat Sloan even wrote Soviet Democracy to describe in detail the system the soviets had built for curious Statesians to read about, and today we have Professor Roland Boer’s Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance to reference.
When it comes to social progressivism, the soviet union was among the best out of their peers, so instead we must look at who was actually repressed outside of the norm. In the USSR, it was the capitalist class, the kulaks, the fascists who were repressed. This is out of necessity for any socialist state. When it comes to working class freedoms, however, the soviet union represented a dramatic expansion. Soviet progressivism was documented quite well in Albert Syzmanski’s Human Rights in the Soviet Union.
The truth, when judged based on historical evidence and contextualization, is that socialism was the best thing to happen to Russia in the last few centuries, and its absence has been devastating.
Capitalism brought with it skyrocketing poverty rates, drug abuse, prostitution, homelessness, crime rates, and lowered life expectancy. An estimated 7 million people died due to the dissolution of socialism in the USSR. To this day, a large majority of post-soviet citizens regret the fall of socialism in Europe. A return to socialism is the only path forward for the post-soviet countries.
Oh wow. So my comment from first hand experience was removed and this soviet propaganda piece is fine?
Nobody lived good under socialism. Maybe the factory chimneys and conveyor belts barely ever stopped but people had no life. You were either slaving in a factory for bread, sossage and a bottle of vodka. Or got sent to the military for years. Or jail.
We were not allowed to speak in our language nor sing. You’d get deported to a military hotspot far away to die or be put in jail for such a crime.
Smartest and most tallanted people and their families were killed or deported. Replaced with ruskies who came to loot and destroy.
Absolutely nobody was glad to live under the oppression of communist russia. While the rest of Europe thrived we lived almost a century behind.
It only brought destruction and pain for us.
I can’t believe I have to talk about this here.
And mods removing my comment on this topic?
Which part of the truth did hurt you so much that you couldn’t resist the power of censorship?
… Unreal. Lemmy. How ironic.
I’d like to a few questions related to your personal experience.
First, what timeframe are you referencing? Second, what Soviet Republic or Warsaw Pact member nation were you living in?
I’d like you to go away. I did not join this community to talk with sovietskies.
That is painful past of my life that I have happily forgotten about.
Please, leave.
This is plainly false, though. I already posted ample sources so I won’t retread old ground, but the idea that socialism was the problem isn’t realistic in the slightest. Western Europe thrived due to imperialism and colonialism, while the USSR aided liberation struggles around the world. This led to sanctions and trade embargoes, limiting access to luxury goods beyond what could be domestically produced. You aren’t speaking truth, but you did start lashing out at people and thus your comment was removed. And no, I’m not a moderator.
I’d like you to go away. I did not join this community to talk with sovietskies.
That is painful past of my life that I have happily forgotten about.
Please, leave.
Because the actual collapse of the USSR made everyone other than the oligarchs deeply miserable, women who were doctors and scientists and engineers became sex workers overnight, you’re just repeating anticommunist nonsense
Actually no. When socialism collapsed we finally were free to do whatever we want. We started our own businesses with our own values that we individually believed in. We were free, at last.
Those on the other hand, who needed socialist forced factory work in order to do something, became total bums and these are the big crybabies who say that ussr took care of them. We have always encouraged them to move to their mother russia, but there you see, it’s much harder to be a bum. So they stay, do nothing and cry about ‘good old times’
These women, if they were educated in medicine or science could continue their careers if they were capable. The choice now was in their own hands. And to be fair, I have never ever heard that post soviet collapse sex work grew in my country.
You, orc girly, clearly have no idea what you are talking about.
It’s truly insane we have to talk about this.
When the ‘proof’ comes from biased sources, is it really proof, though? They don’t promote critical thinking and “doing your own research” if that critical thinking and research doesn’t lead to a conclusion that fits the instance narrative.
What sources count as “unbiased?” All sources have bias, that doesn’t mean they are wrong inherently.
Oh hey, there he is. Knew he’d show up here as soon as I made that comment. Is there just a button on .ml that people can click when someone mentions China/Russia/etc. to summon you? I’m 99% sure it was you who I had the discussion with that I’m referencing below. I have no intention of engaging with you again.
I sort by “New Comments” and browse Lemmy.ml locally. I don’t know who you are, I just responded to what I felt warranted doing so.
The proof comes in the form of the State Department or the Library of Congress of the United States admitting to doing the things that they’re accused of doing and it’s done in a similar way that people are learning from the Epstein files.
If you still don’t think that this isn’t proof, then there’s nothing anyone can do for you.
I don’t know what you’re referencing specifically; I was temp-banned from .ml for citing accounts from people who used to live in China and left the country as sources for what life in China was like for them, and was provided counter-‘proof’ from Chinese state media. That was basically all I needed to see to understand that, while I’m on board with the stance that western sources are not always accurate, what’s being pushed there is an agenda, not a search for truth.
Thanks for the heads up buddy. I’ll keep that in mind but that won’t keep me from speaking what I believe in. I’d prefer that my opinion gets dismantled by something more based, so I can change my mind.
Sh.it just.works is like the 4chan of Lemmy instances.
You might have better luck on Lemmy.dbzer0.com, they’re extremely based and have good political takes.
You’re only going to get that from people who have dedicated their lives to learning political theory and I can speak from experience that you’re not going to find it on your current home instance.