Jeanne-Paul Marat

Nimrod who forgot their password and had to make a new account.

Young American Orthodox Marxist-Leninist Nucleocrat. Han Suyin’s biggest fan. Jacobin [in the based way and not in the american liberal way] and friend of the people. Any pronouns are fine, but prefer she/her or they/them

Elaboration:https://lemmygrad.ml/post/10116673

Original account:https://lemmygrad.ml/u/King_Simp

Substack:https://open.substack.com/pub/journaldemarat?r=2lr83e

  • 10 Posts
  • 22 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 19th, 2025

help-circle
  • Trump is the exact embodiment of the Eugene Debs quote about war. He says he would’ve won the war by bombing Vietnam.

    “The master class has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles. The master class had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject class has had nothing to gain and all to lose - especially their lives.”

    ive never understood this contrarianism when it comes to this here. The rich sent the poor to kill other poor. Thats bad, and Trump’s and other rich folks ability to dodge the draft while the poor either had to fight or go to prison was an immoral injustice.

    Honestly whenever people talk about this stuff it reeks of moralism. Myopic, and undialetically caterwailing to own the libs.

    Yes, he should’ve dodged the draft, but draft dodging the way he did was a rich, Bourgeois privilege thats been a thing since the civil war [if not earlier]. He’s also shown his willingness to send others to kill Iranians and Venezualans. Thats exactly the type of hypocrisy us communists always criticize. Except to own the libs I suppose



  • Right right. Personally [since its in my feild] im biased towards nuclear energy. But Melachon would generally be a net positive. Although the recent platform i read from LFI was that they were pulling out of the integrated command structure and not the alliance entirely so im not entirely sure.

    Im also biased towards Melenchon because im used to older men like him being more KKE or Galloway types in terms of social conservatism or being lethargic in terms of action like Zyuganov, so I’ll let him get away with a lot more than I probably shouldn’t tbh.


  • For a much more in depth explanation, I reccomend Cheng Enfu’s “China’s Economic Dialetic.”

    Basically the three main things id argue are

    1.they are, but given how reliant on international trade they are, they’d rather do it gradually and through economic pressure than through polticial mandate. This can be seen in how SOE’s have been told to compete on the market more, which they will have a natural advantage with.

    2.China wants to have a primary-secondary distribution system. I.e, by 2049 they want to have a distribution based on work system be primary, but with a supplemental market system to make up for deficits. Then later after that move to a need based system with distribution by work to make up deficits

    3.Id argue socialism in one country is…economically oversimplified, but not in the Trotskyite way. What I mean is that, even at China’s size, they cant have everything. And in my interpretation of marxist longue durée dialectical materialism, a full proper transition to the higher stages of socialism can only occur as the rest of the world transitions to socialism [i.e, how the Dutch practiced capitalism but still fell behind to feudal france and such]. Additionally, development of automation [just as the development of industrialization before it] will probably greatly speed up this process once it is more viable



  • Yeah. Its also the fact that france is not like the US or UK. 70%+ of electricity production is nuclear. If they just prioritized renewable over nuclear itd be fine, but its the fact that they want a complete phase out, going from increasing renewables by about 50% [ish, just going off wikipedia here] to increase renewable share from 17 to about 25% to wipe out fossil fuels, to a whopping 560% increase to account for both nuclear and fossil fuels.

    My other thing really is like “this is the hill youre gonna die on? Really?” Its like when that one canidate for the French throne wouldn’t accept the throne unless to tricolor was replaced. I dont think there’s a lot of people who wouldn’t support them if they didnt have a 100% anti nuclear platform, but there’s probably a lot of people who are, for good reason, skeptical of the idea of repeating the German folly in a country more reliant on nuclear power.



  • My soft spot for Melachon hardening after I find out he’s anti nuclear energy [Im going to actually lose it with European leftists]

    But no seriously why are European greens and such so anti nuclear. I get not being vehemently pro nuclear, but why am I apparently having to be pro nuclear with neoliberals and Trumpians on my side?

    Edit: also what’s with banning flights between 11pm and 6 am? That honestly felt like a really random policy proposal





  • I think the problem with the purge was not necessarily those who were purged, but that there was no next generation to replace them.

    Yes in China Deng survived, but honestly from what ive seen of Bukharin im not sure if the two are entirely comparable. But the crucial thing is that there was a generation of CPC members that could survive the turbulence of reform and opening up, the June 4th incident, etc.

    This wasn’t just the purge of course, given ww2 took more CPSU members, but if you look at China, the DPRK, and Vietnam compared to the USSR and eastern Europe, id say its the people’s ability to have faith and interact with the system that led to their survival compared to eastern Europe’s downfall.


  • Its hard to say exactly, since I think the collapse of the USSR is probably one of the best examples where Marxist Longue durée analysis should be used.

    However, if I can try at least

    1.Preventing Krushev’s secret speech/takeover in general

    This is probably the lynchpyn of the whole thing. You had many young comrades coming into the party [most notably Yeltsin and Gorbachev] and Krushchev’s first act would essentially shatter faith in the system high and low, much as how the Thermidorian reaction shattered the revolutionary spirit of france and gave way to Bonapartist cynicism.

    Not only that, but the so called “anti-party group” generally had the better economic policies, and more experience.

    2.An earlier Detente if possible

    Obviously this is as much the west’s ball game as it was the USSR’s. But putting so many resources into the military was one of the leading reasons of the decline. The Cuban missile crisis, ironically enough, was probably a missed opportunity for more comprehensive agreements on the matter.

    3.The party remaining connected to the people

    This one is a bit obvious, which is why its here instead of at the top. But the problem that occured with Perestroika is that the USSR was like a pressure cooker. There needed to be some way to release the steam and there never was. Breshnev was probably a really good example here of what not to do. His period in office didnt solve problems, leading to this pressure build up.

    This also goes for eastern Europe in general tbh. Although I do agree with soviet intervention in the most high profile incidents, so im not sure about that tbh.

    Overall what probably killed it most was the sino-soviet split, which, while Krushev was important, was brewing from the days of the internationale. [The third int is its own topic I’ll probably talk about one day though]





  • That wasn’t my point. My point was that, in the aggregate, people will push past ingrained social conservatism [and other beliefs] if they think someone will support their material conditions or if they’ve become disillusioned with the system.

    I brought up the demsoc in Florida because Florida is the last place you’d really expect a demsoc to run, considering its full of Gusanos and retire-ees.

    Obviously voting doesn’t translate to a revolutionary vanguard. But what im saying is that the start, the actual conversion to socialist beliefs, can happen if its impossible to deny. And really once the economic reality hits, the vanguard isnt too far behind.


  • I do have some two cents about the midterms in the US.

    To be clear, I dont like the democrats. Not only for the obvious reasons but also personal ones related to my family and also local politics.

    Anyway, I think this really should be a wakeup call for a lot of tailists. Not just in the USA [Maupin, Haz, A"C"P, etc.] But also like the BSW and WPB and CPGB [although I do understand the leaders of these parties are often opportunists in general and also somehow self defeatingly hateful {I’m looking at you Galloway}].

    The democrats basically ran on an anti trump platform, and Talorico himself, to my knowledge, wasn’t doing the anti-trans dance democrats did during 2024, although honestly I dont know a lot of his political positions. But even in Florida they nearly elected a democratic socialist (who wasn’t given support by the dem establishment, shockerrrr)

    What I mean is that, even in deeply conservative areas like Alabama, they’re able to elect democrats [including a transgender democrat] if thats their only option that they can do.

    Ergo, principled socialist parties are able to win and shouldn’t focus on tailing social conservatives. I know this was obvious to a lot of people already but even I, a Trans woman, was kinda sympathetic to the general philosophy even if I didnt personally like tailists, until now.

    (Side note: im combining tailists and “reactionary socialists” here, even though I can acknowledge they are different things. Reactionary socialists is my own term that generally doesn’t seek evolution from the soviet days or from other AES projects and just lazily says “let’s do what they did.” I.e, the soviet union was homophobic so we should be homophobic)



  • Its hard to say exactly.

    But like, take maybe Nikolai Yezhov vs Lin Biao. Like if you look up stuff about Lin Biao, you’ll get the general story, the general explanation of the gang of four and his opportunism, and conflicting reports and what happened when he died. But its not impossible to find a fairly balanced story about what happened, and with a fair amount of sources of internal happenings

    But then for Yezhov, basically the only stuff you’ll find is the western story on the matter, with the general propaganda about him. And then even trying to dig deeper involves digging through a lot more layers of propaganda to get information.

    Another thing is the government of the ussr vs the government of the prc. Looking up how the prc works is fairly straightforward, and beyond the usual anticom stuff you can get a decent idea on the matter. But for the USSR, especially during the Stalin era, it very much feels like the answer is handwaved away as “stalin did everything” which is objectively impossible but whatever.