Sharjeel Imam makes an argument for more cognisance of religion amongst Indian Marxists. To be honest, religion is some sort of an elephant in the room for the Indian left - since majority of the country (across religions) is inspired by the same “Hindu Social Order” which gave birth to casteism, and with it Brahminical patriarchy. And in a time like this, relating it back to the patchwork by INC in the independence-era Indian era is fresh analysis.

What Sharjeel says is undeniably true - secularism becomes irreconcilable with religious doctrines if it imposes areligiousity militantly. In a deeply religious country such as India (where, even if you’re an atheist your rights are not recognised), Marxism must think about what secularism means to them. I think some outlets like voxummah and a few critically aligned YouTubers do this abroad, whereas in India, there is a lack of discourse on this in present day.

Whereas, we are seeing the normalisation of the apartheid politics through Muslim disenfranchisement (the current wave of protests are only against a particular individual), and any revolution here will be unsuccessful if it doesn’t include Muslims and other caste minorities. Secularism needs to give a space for practice of religion - and issues like Waqf board, human development indicators, urban development, all show that equality is intrinsically linked to material resources made available to communities. Whereas, capitalism creates artificial scarcity that deprives some communities of their needs.