(This takes 3½ minutes to read.)
In September 1940, a heterogeneous group gathered around the Mandel family and formed a resistance organisation called Vrank en Vrij (Frank and Free), composed of about 100, mainly young, activists of whom 13 were Trotskyists led by Ernest Mandel.¹¹⁰
Henri Mandel, Ernest’s father had been far-sighted enough to buy a stencil duplicator before the German invasion and, with this, the group was able to produce, from October 1940 to August 1942, 3–4000 copies per month of Het Vrije Woord (Freedom of Speech) for distribution in Antwerp and its surroundings.¹¹¹ Het Vrije Woord did not have any particular line, concentrating on anti-Nazi propaganda, news of Allied victories and warnings of the severity of the coming persecution of the Jews.
Following increased police activity in Antwerp aimed at the Jewish population, the Mandels and other Jewish members of the group fled to Brussels where they started to produce a German language paper of the same name, Das Freie Wort, aimed at the occupying forces. This contained a mixture of demoralising stories of the way in which Germany was losing the war and exhortations to act against the [Third Reich]. For instance, January 1943 issue:
The assurance that the Belgian resistance movement has repeatedly given you that its fight is not aimed at you, but only against the occupying forces as a representative of the accursed Hitler régime, is sincerely meant. The leaders of the Belgian resistance movement recently issued instructions to their followers not to harm any peace-loving German soldier. It is therefore your duty to reward like with like!
Help the brave fighters of the Belgian resistance movement to escape the persecution of the Gestapo. Open the gates of the prisons for them as soon as you have the opportunity.
Das Freie Wort was produced more or less regularly from the end of 1943 through to the liberation of Belgium. They did manage to recruit two Wehrmacht soldiers in Brussels, which helped greatly with the distribution of the paper.
When Ernest Mandel arrived in Brussels, he contacted Abram Wajnsztok (alias Abram Léon), a Polish immigrant of Jewish heritage who was one of the principal motivators of the Trotskyist Parti Communiste Révolutionnaire (PCR, Revolutionary Communist Party, previously Parti Socialiste Révolutionnaire). The PCR had sections in Brussels and Antwerp, with its main working class bases in Charleroi and above all the Borinage, where it had over 600 members.
However, the Borinage group, mainly miners, was based around Walter Dauge. Following his arrest, first by the Belgian police in 1939 and then again by the [Fascist] authorities after the invasion, Dauge dropped out of working class politics, becoming the deputy mayor of his hometown and was deeply involved in corruption and black marketeering. He was murdered in 1944, either by the Partisans Armés or by his old comrades from the PCR or by a rival gang of black marketeers. There was no investigation and no one missed him. Be that as it may, Dauge’s defection broke the major Trotskyist base in Belgium.
The May 1941 strikes in Liège reinvigorated the PCR and, under Abram Leon’s leadership, they restarted publication of La Voie de Lénine (Lenin’s Way). The PCR concentrated its efforts on Liège and Charleoi, with Mandel taking responsibility for Liège and Leon for Charleoi.
In Liège, André Renard had expanded his base in the Fédération des Métallurgistes de Liège to set up the Mouvement Syndical Unifié (MSU, United Trade-Union Movement). While he maintained friendly relations with the PCR who printed the MSU paper, Travail, the Trotskyists had little different to offer and only managed to recruit a handful of militants.
However, in the Charleroi mines matters were different, an experienced Trotskyist militant, J. Davister with about 25 comrades, managed to build a movement among the coal miners of the region, leading strikes and other actions from 1942 onwards. They published a clandestine newspaper, Le Réveil des Mineurs: Organe de la Fédération de Lutte des Mineurs de Charleroi. By early 1944, this initiative led to the setting up the Mouvement des Délégués (Delegates’ Movement), which was the principal trade union organisation in the Charleoi mines.
However, this regional hegemony brought down the hostility of the PCB and when the Comités de Lutte Syndicale, the Mouvement Syndical Unifié merged with the old [Confédération Générale du Travail de Belgique] to form a single trade union federation, the rank and file of the Mouvement des Délégués, disgusted with the accusations of collaboration that the Communist press was levelling at Davister, walked out. The disunity disappointed many of the Carleroi miners and the Mouvement des Délégués went into decline and with it the remaining Trotskyist mass base in Belgium.¹¹²
Despite the proximity of Belgium and the Nord-Pas-de-Calais and the fact that they were both administered from Brussels, their pathways to working class resistance and the form it took were remarkably different. We shall later consider in detail the differences between the two regions, suffice to say at this stage that, despite these differences, the similarities are astounding and we see in this part of northern Europe the most complete example anywhere of a combination of the economic class struggle with anti-fascist armed resistance.
