The Sorites paradox (/soʊˈraɪtiːz/),[1] sometimes known as the paradox of the heap, is a paradox that results from vague predicates.[2] A typical formulation involves a heap of sand, from which grains are removed individually. With the assumption that removing a single grain does not cause a heap not to be considered a heap anymore, the paradox is to consider what happens when the process is repeated enough times that only one grain remains and if it is still a heap. If not, then the question asks when it changed from a heap to a non-heap.[3]

There are many variations of the sorites paradox, some of which allow consideration of the difference between “being” and “seeming”, that is, between a question of fact and a question of perception;[2] this may be seen to be relevant when the argument hinges on each change being “imperceptible”.

Another formulation is to start with a grain of sand, which is clearly not a heap, and then assume that adding a single grain of sand to something that is not a heap does not cause it to become a heap. Inductively, this process can be repeated as much as one wants without ever constructing a heap.[2][3] A more natural formulation of this variant is to assume a set of colored chips exists such that two adjacent chips vary in color too little for human eyesight to be able to distinguish between them. Then by induction on this premise, humans would not be able to distinguish between any colors.[2]

The removal of one drop from the ocean, will not make it “not an ocean” (it is still an ocean), but since the volume of water in the ocean is finite, eventually, after enough removals, even a litre of water left is still an ocean.

This paradox can be reconstructed for a variety of predicates, for example, with “tall”, “rich”, “old”, “blue”, “bald”, and so on. The version about baldness, where it is argued that adding a single hair does not make a bald man no longer bald, is known as the “falakros”, from the Greek for “bald” (φαλακρός).[12][13] Bertrand Russell argued that all of natural language, even logical connectives, is vague; moreover, representations of propositions are vague.[14]

  • echo@lemmy.today
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    5 days ago

    This really doesn’t seem so much like a paradox as a lack of definition(s).

    What is the definition of a heap? How big are the grains/drops?

    It’s generally the same as saying when does a collection quit being ‘a few’? For me, a few is actually defined as being 3 or very close to it. So 2 and 4 are not ‘a few’. Two is a couple and 4 is, well, 4. If the size being removed from or added to 3.0 is 0.01 or even 0.10, then it’s still a few. If the size being removed/added, then that is when it is no longer a few.

    • Tomtits@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      5 days ago

      It’s close to the adage “two’s a couple, three’s a crowd”

      So just so crowd for heap and paradox solved

  • Jilanico@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    5 days ago

    In my mind, the moment the pile no longer has a hill shape, it’s no longer a heap. I think the definition and etymology of the word support this. I also think “heap” implies the objects are solids. You don’t have a heap of water or gas as they do not take a hill shape when concentrated in an area.

    Edit: I think the definition of the word is what matters. For the ocean example, the moment the body of water ceases to separate 2 or more continents it is no longer an ocean. The definition of some words are imprecise so in those cases we’ll have to accept some amibiguity. It’s admittedly not a satisfying solution but the blame falls on the ambiguity of the word used.

  • Cosmoooooooo@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    5 days ago

    This is just boundaries. Where do you draw the boundary between two sizes?

    It tries to eliminate boundaries by making incremental changes until boundaries don’t exist anymore. Which is bullshit. “But who decides the difference between a medium soda and a large soda?!?!” It’s not a philosophical question, it’s just someone setting an arbitrary boundary.

    When is a heap not a heap? When someone says so.