To better understand empiricism and dialectical materialism, I think it’s worth examining this video and the ideas.
The video claims empiricism claims we can understand the external reality outside of our subjective points of view. But my understanding of empiricism is different. I think empiricists say humans can only ever claim there are regularities in our perception of reality. That is why statistics and mathematics become central to empiricism, so that we can clearly understand those regularities.
As to the video’s characterization of dialectical materialism, I agree that there are some processes for which our subjectivity is critical to better understand phenomena. However, I’m not sure that applies to all of reality.
For example, there are some generative processes of reality that we can very confidently say are independent of human perception. Gravity. The sun’s fusion. Light. The bending of light. Evaporation. Photosynthesis.
That is why I like the critical realist perspective. From that point of view, science is an attempt at understanding the generative processes of reality. And sometimes, those processes involve humans and so science tries to understand those too.
But in my view, trying to insist on the subjective nature of gravity instead of seeing gravity as a force that is independent subjectivity is not useful and doesn’t reflect how many of our most useful conceptions of reality are.
trying to insist on the subjective nature of gravity instead of seeing gravity as a force that is independent subjectivity
They’re not claiming that gravity is subjective. They’re claiming that every conception of gravity that we have come to throughout history, we came to through our subjective selves. Gravity exists objectively, but our limited and imperfect understanding of it comes to us subjectively.
our limited and imperfect understanding of it comes to us subjectively.
Yes, and how could it be any different? I can’t even imagine, not without making really strong (meaning far fetched) metaphysical claims.


