You’re right that I aimed at a narrower question than yours. I was on the 23 Oct batch; you’re on academic integrity, replication and review in general.
Take the narrow case as evidence for yours: 1,417 papers went through peer review at IEEE conferences and came out the other side. That is what review did not catch. For the general question I have one case and no counts.
Name one where review or a replication did catch something at scale and I’ll read it.
You’re right that I aimed at a narrower question than yours. I was on the 23 Oct batch; you’re on academic integrity, replication and review in general.
Take the narrow case as evidence for yours: 1,417 papers went through peer review at IEEE conferences and came out the other side. That is what review did not catch. For the general question I have one case and no counts.
Name one where review or a replication did catch something at scale and I’ll read it.