• 0 Posts
  • 127 Comments
Joined 14 days ago
cake
Cake day: November 5th, 2026

help-circle
  • Sure, and further interpretation would be that the severing of any sort of responsibility for guaranteeing the material conditions of their workforce knowing that absent selling their labor, a individual risks precarity thus ensuring a steady pool of cheap, readily available labor, which increasingly became seen as a feature for capitalists, not a bug.

    And that said court system, along with other tools of coercion and control within the state, were directly designed and structured by the ruling class to protect their class interests and sustain the necessary reproduction of exploitation for maintaining this system.


  • You might even go further and say that capitalists in the 17th and early 18th century openly talked about how slavery was increasingly an inferior form of control. That with industrialization and urban concentration dragged down capital accumulation for capitalists and that in fact precarity of unemployment, starvation, loss of social status, and the ability to easily replace their workforce and offload the burdens you speak of was a cheaper and equally effective way to reproduce the same functional exploitation.


  • I mean on the one hand, sure

    On the other hand, slave-owners sort of had to actually make sure you had food, shelter, and healthy enough to sustain their workforce. Wal-mart don’t give a fuck if you have to sleep in your car and can’t make rent, show up in uniform and don’t complain or they will take the next desperate person and you risk being arrested for violating modern vagrancy laws.

    People can interpret that how they will.




  • Sure, I agree 100%, there is personal responsibility and culpability, my point though was just that when things focus exclusively on appeals to personal responsibility without putting that into a larger material analysis and organizing strategy around changing the social and economic structures that shape society we risk substituting individual moral reckoning for the organized political struggle actually required to change society.

    And absent that structural and material framework and an organizing strategy to accompany it, that often ends up leading to people focusing on policing one another as an end to itself and then getting frustrated when policing people’s social choices and thoughts largely just produces a circular firing squad that can do more to alienate than affect change.



  • Culture and society are shaped by the economic and material conditions people live under, and the institutions, power structures, class relations, coercions, and propaganda that reproduce them.

    Those systems have to be confronted and fundamentally changed and reorganized for any hope of lasting change.

    Asking for deep reflection from the masses is only going to be effective insomuch that people’s raised consciousness actually produces a sufficiently correct understanding if these interwoven dynamics and organizes toward changing that effectively.

    Otherwise, absent a structural analysis and related strategy of change, you are just offloading blame onto people that are themselves products of forces that have shown their adaptability to reproduce the same hierarchies, inequalities, and systems of exploitation across generations, regardless of how much a specific society’s moral attitudes evolve or change.


  • I gave you your 60 minute Digital Foundry technical breakdown.

    They are in fact considered by quite a lot of people as the gold standard in analyzing the technical side of games(I am aware this is a subjective statement and as such may further trigger you into another furried rage, prompting demands I do a thorough statistical comparative analysis of gamers by conducting multiple population surveys to prove the accuracy of this statement, but I wont, so deal with it).

    Beyond that though

    No, I don’t, cause it’s not that serious.

    I am sorry GTA has done this to you, and I hope that you are able to seek out some friends and family to get you thru what seems like a rough time in your life.




  • TBH there is valid criticism wrapped in all this reactionary posturing but the latter is exposing you a bit.

    As someone that you can peek their post history as saying on record I am not a big GTA fan and have never finished one. Find them to be style over substance and a mile wide and an inch deep in terms of the gameplay loops and fun factor, I STILL think this is a bit much.

    Look at the Digital Foundry review. This is objectively the most technically impressive game ever created. It is doing things with lighting and technical complexity no game has done. The world is unmatched. And by accounts I have read, they have also objectively improved some of the major complaints about control clunkiness, the gunplay, and opened up more of the mission structures. And frankly, unless you got a advance copy, there is no way you made it thru the whole story yet. Which love it or not, is seemingly what they are resting their hat on similar to RDR2.

    Personally I will wait for more feedback and decide whether to get it on PC when it arrives, but more to the point, we know what the review industry is, which is one populated by fandom more than auteur analysis, and the business model is dependent on a parasitic relationship with developers(play nice or you might not get review copies). Sorry, but welcome to capitalism!




  • There does come a point where I lose interest speaking to genocide apologists, which you have just crossed over into

    Here is the fucking facts: Israel CANNOT in their own words sustain their military campaigns without US arms. AT NO POINT did Biden even TRY to meaningfully use the lever of US arms restrictions(which he had a legal obligation to restrict under the Leahy law but broke it) to curb the genocide and uphold a permanent ceasefire using the IMMENSE power of US influence over Israel.

    No amount of Jewish tropes or wishcasting changes these fucking facts

    Biden aided and abetted a genocide he had the power, and OBLIGATION to take actions to stop but refused.

    Just because you want to concoct whatever fantasy in your head about how Israel could have somehow kept going, it DOESNT FUCKING MATTER! HE STILL ASSISSTED IN A GENOCIDE

    I don’t think I have ever seen a more thorough embodiment of the phrase scratch a liberal and watch a fascist bleed.

    Just put a D behind someones name, tell them how bad the other person is, and you are showing there is literally NOTHING you won’t excuse a Democrat from doing. And ironically, this is EXACTLY the sort of logic that Trumpers use to justify endless support for Republicans.




  • It would be even more pathetic if you are doing enlightened centrism in US politics as a POC in 2026…and MLK and others had words for them too.

    And no, that is not what centrism is defined as. Find me a single respected dictionary or encyclopedia that defines Centrism and simply majoritarianism? Its funny, cause my disagreement here is actually trying to help you appear less reactionary. Cause at least by the actual definition centrism is simply “adherence to moderate political views or policies; careful avoidance of any political position that could be construed as too far right or left.” In your definition, if you lived in Germany in 1932 you would be voting for the coalition that put Hitler in power. At least in my definition you would instead be the SPD.



  • I love that in this little hypothetical you made up you basically managed to not just do apologetics for Biden’s genocidal culpability but drag in dual loyalty tropes about Jews too. Then blame them for everything.

    Spoiler: Abdul El Sayed just won a race on calling Israel a genocidal apartheid state and defunding them entiriely…He still won a majority of Jewish voters and only performed 1 point less than how rabid Zionist Elissa Slotkin performed in the 72 largest Jewish precincts in Michigan. If anything, Abdul El Sayed shows that had Biden/Harris run on a more economically populist, anti genocide campaign, and taken actions against Israel earlier, they would have won Michigan and there would be no Trump. And also, which seems relevent for you, Jews aren’t a monolith and they aren’t all taking marching orders from Israel.

    So sorry, your fantasy doesn’t hold up to the reality we have in front of us right now.

    Biden was a willing accomplice to genocide and no amount of mental gymnastics is removing his culpability for it.

    Maybe try developing a politics that is built around policies, morals, and outcomes, not tribal loyalties and lesser evil rationalizations. If you can’t draw a red line at genocide, you aren’t someone that can be trusted to draw a redline at anything as long as a D is by their name. And that is how you repeat the same cycle we are seeing in Gaza.